The Lombard Review
World

How far will Japan let the yen fall?

Threshold ambiguity as deterrent

The Bank of Japan, Tokyo
The Bank of Japan, TokyoPhoto: Suicasmo / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

The yen has reached the danger zone, sliding toward 151.8 per dollar—its weakest level in thirty-four years. Officials from the Ministry of Finance have escalated their verbal warnings to maximum alert, declaring that they will not rule out 'any steps' to counter speculative moves. Yet Tokyo faces an acute strategic dilemma in deploying foreign exchange intervention.

The U.S. Treasury Building, Washington
The U.S. Treasury Building, WashingtonPhoto: MeanieHyaena / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

The Threshold Conundrum

Intervening at an explicit numeric threshold gives hedge funds a target to test. Furthermore, spending foreign currency reserves to support the yen while the Bank of Japan refuses to deliver aggressive quantitative tightening or substantial rate hikes is an exercise in futility. Intervention can punish over-leveraged speculators temporarily, but it cannot alter the fundamental reality of wide interest rate differentials.

The Lower Manhattan skyline from Liberty Island
The Lower Manhattan skyline from Liberty IslandPhoto: Percival Kestreltail / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Tokyo's verbal warnings are losing their bite; currency intervention without aggressive Bank of Japan tightening is merely a multi-billion-dollar donation to foreign exchange carry traders.