The Lombard Review
Economy Special Report

Anniversary: Two years of calls, checked

Forecast error decomposition

The Federal Reserve Board's Eccles Building on Constitution Avenue
The Federal Reserve Board's Eccles Building on Constitution AvenuePhoto: AgnosticPreachersKid / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Two years after this column launched amidst soaring inflation and aggressive rate increases, the macroeconomic landscape has completed a remarkable full circle. When we commenced in September 2022, central banks were embarking on panic tightening; today, the Federal Reserve is preparing to initiate its first interest rate cut. Decomposing two years of market calls reveals essential lessons in cyclical humility.

Workers on a construction site
Workers on a construction sitePhoto: Boudoirphotographyguide / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

The Forecasting Scorecard

Consensus failed by underestimating the resilience of corporate balance sheets, the cushioning effect of locked-in low debt coupons, and the power of federal fiscal deficits to counteract monetary tightening. Yet the laws of financial gravity were not repealed; their transmission was merely delayed. As rate cuts commence, the true test of post-pandemic debt structures is about to begin.

The trading floor of the Frankfurt Stock Exchange
The trading floor of the Frankfurt Stock ExchangePhoto: Ank Kumar / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Two years of macroeconomic forecasting have proved that structural balance-sheet cushions can delay monetary policy transmission, but they cannot permanently immunise the economy from capital costs.