The Lombard Review
Economy

2023: The recession that never came

Consensus recession call failed

The trading floor of the Frankfurt Stock Exchange
The trading floor of the Frankfurt Stock ExchangePhoto: Ank Kumar / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

As 2023 draws to a close, economists and macroeconomic forecasters must confront a humbling reality: the universal recession call that dominated market consensus twelve months ago was spectacularly wrong. Late-2022 surveys showed an unprecedented sixty-five per cent probability of a US recession in 2023. Instead, the American economy accelerated, posting robust GDP growth and defying the fastest tightening cycle in generations.

Lower Manhattan seen from Jersey City
Lower Manhattan seen from Jersey CityPhoto: King of Hearts / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

The Anatomy of a Forecasting Failure

Forecasters failed because they applied mechanical models calibrated to previous cycles, underestimating the extraordinary cushion of pandemic household excess savings, the locking-in of ultra-low corporate and mortgage debt, and massive federal fiscal expansion. The private sector was effectively insulated from the initial rate shock. The recession was not canceled; its timeline was simply decoupled from standard historical lags.

The Marriner S. Eccles Building, headquarters of the Federal Reserve Board, Washington
The Marriner S. Eccles Building, headquarters of the Federal Reserve Board, WashingtonPhoto: Federalreserve / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

The utter failure of 2023’s consensus recession call is a masterclass in macroeconomic humility, proving that structural balance-sheet insulation can defeat traditional monetary models.